An AI music company can license a recording and still owe something for the song inside it.
That distinction sounds basic. In music licensing, it is where fortunes disappear.
On September 30, independent publisher organizations IMPEL and IMPF published seven principles for AI licensing. Their sharpest demand is that the composition — the melody and lyrics created by songwriters — must be valued at least equally with the master recording.
It is not a signed deal. It is a negotiating line, and songwriters want the industry to stop stepping over it.
One track contains two different rights
Every commercial recording normally contains at least two major copyrights:
- the composition, controlled by songwriters and publishers;
- the master recording, controlled by the performer, label or whoever financed the recording.
AI training can implicate both. A model may learn from the sound of a finished recording while also absorbing patterns from the underlying melody, harmony or lyric. A license that pays only one side does not make the other side disappear.
Labels are large, concentrated negotiators. Publishing is fragmented across major publishers, independents, collecting societies and millions of writers. That imbalance can make the master the visible prize while the song becomes an afterthought.
The seven-principle push
The IMPEL and IMPF framework calls for authorization, transparency and compensation across several stages of the AI pipeline. Its central economic position is unusually direct: the song should be valued no less than the recording.
The groups also argue that licensing should account for:
- past use of works in model training;
- use of works in future training;
- generated outputs that exploit protected material;
- meaningful reporting and audit rights;
- respect for creators' moral and personality rights.
The National Music Publishers' Association made a similar equal-valuation push earlier in 2026 when announcing licensing initiatives involving Udio and KLAY. The repeated language suggests coordination, not a one-off complaint.
Why “equal value” is a fight, not a fact
No public rule requires an AI company to split its music budget equally between compositions and masters. The new framework states what publishers believe a fair deal should look like.
Actual agreements remain confidential. Public announcements often promise consent, attribution and compensation without revealing royalty percentages, advances, training rates or how money reaches individual creators.
That means nobody outside the contracts can honestly say songwriters now receive equal AI licensing income. They do not have that guarantee. What they have is a clearer collective demand.
The money may arrive at three different moments
Traditional streaming pays after a listener plays a track. AI licensing can create value earlier and in more places:
- Training: a protected work enters a dataset or influences a model.
- Generation: the system produces an output connected to that learned material.
- Exploitation: the output is distributed, licensed or monetized.
Publishers are arguing that compensation cannot be reduced to the final stream. If a catalog helps create the model's capability, the catalog produced value before any listener pressed play.
That idea will shape whether AI music becomes a recurring royalty business, a one-time data buyout or some hybrid of both.
What independent songwriters should ask
If a publisher, label or platform offers an AI-related agreement, ask questions that separate the song from the recording:
- Which right is being licensed — composition, master, voice, likeness or all four?
- Does permission cover past training, future training, generated outputs or each separately?
- Is compensation an advance, a usage fee, a royalty or a complete buyout?
- Can you withdraw future use, and what happens to an already-trained model?
- Will you receive reports detailed enough to verify payment?
A sentence promising “creator compensation” does not answer any of them.
The quiet power shift
The AI music licensing era began as a fight between technology companies and record labels. Songwriters are making clear that it cannot end there.
A model does not hear a master recording without also encountering a song. If the new market rewards the polish of the recording but discounts the composition beneath it, the oldest imbalance in the music business will be rebuilt inside its newest technology.
The seven principles do not settle the price. They make it harder to pretend the song has none.
Sources
SoundGen Team
Written by the team building SoundGen


